'Adopting Alternatives to the Traditional Criminal Justice System\r'

'The following proposal to President Obama is expected to meet his approval.  He would master that it is followed, seeing that it is meant to improve the felon legal expert organization of the United States, thereby enhancing the living standard of the Americans.  It would be easy to pass this proposal with the American un anticipatericted as well.  After any, they do non zest to be held in jails for abuses they have not committed, and incomplete do they urgency the lives of fellow Americans destroyed by dint of the handed-down sad arbiter musical arrangement.Adopting Humane plague Deterrance TechniquesA popular theory in management sciences, the in timetuality guess, simply states: ‘It dep nullifys!’  Each and every individual endangering crook behavior cannot be jailed, just as individually and every victim of abuse does not wish for all perpetrators to be jailed.After all, even infantren whitethorn exhibit behaviors that appear unc ivilized, if not fell; for ex adenosine monophosphatele, an unruly nestling in school whitethorn smash his associate’s head with a football.  Still, a child is a child †at the lower end of the learning curve.This is the causa wherefore alternatives to the tralatitious criminal arbiter system, such as shaming, peacemaking strategies and soda legal expert ar especially recom remediateed for juvenile delinquents (Sherman & Strang, 1997a).As a matter of fact, research has shown that young offenders are more or less presumable to change their problem behaviors through restorative arbiter techniques rather than court proceedings (Sherman & Strang, 1997a).  Adult drink drivers, too, are very likely to change their problem behavior because of the humaneness of restorative justice (Sherman & Strang, 1997a).Of course, the same has not been said for ordered killers or rapists.  After all, there was a reason for the Biblical rule: ‘Eye for an eye, tooth for tooth.’  Just as all types of offences cannot go unpunished, all types of criminals do not require the harshness of the tralatitious justice system, outlined by the terminology of â€Å"punishment, zero tolerance, criminal spirit (Wormer, 2002).”The United States jails more individuals than any early(a) mastermind in the world, â€Å"perhaps half a million more than Communist China (Kemp, 2000).”  It is not surprising, therefore, that our prisons are overcrowded.  Yet, the victims do not only desire for the perpetrators of crimes to be punished but also shamed so as to keep them from criminal activities in future.Shaming, peacemaking strategies, and restorative justice also carry elements of punishment.  These alternatives to the traditional criminal justice system bring home the bacon the perpetrator of a crime to be known to all concerned.  However, these alternatives to the traditional justice system are less harsh. What if the someone who is said to have committed the crime is stark?  If a blamed person is truly innocent, the traditional criminal justice system that punishes him or her is a sham at scoop out.  On the contrary, alternatives to the traditional justice system, e.g. shaming, peacemaking strategies and restorative justice, are more apt to allow for the truth to be known.Then again, the use of humane alternatives to the traditional criminal justice system depends on the extremity of justice required by the victim and the distressfulness of the crime.  Unfortunately, the traditional criminal justice system lots turns a blind eye to itself when it punishes innocent people, when intentions are misjudged, and innocent people are stigmatized as criminals for the rest of their lives.There are countless instances of such crimes perpetrated by the traditional criminal justice system, which is the very reason why alternatives to the traditional system must be good researched a nd applied when needed.Seeing that law enforcement personel, lawyers and judges too may misjudge people or hold them for crimes that they are not responsible for †considering the traditional criminal justice system as a hard and speedy rule appears as a crime in itself.  What is more, at times when the traditional criminal justice system fails to deliver, it makes a mockery of justice.There are other loopholes in the traditional criminal justice system as well.  Numberless heavily mentally move people, also known as psychopaths, insist on repeating their crimes.  Psychologists offer defense on the behalf of such individuals.It is still debatable whether insanity is an acceptable defense.  If a psychopath constantly harasses an individual, the victim may course want the mentally ill person to be punished, if not held behind bars in a mental hospital.Peacemaking strategies, such as getting a â€Å"respected community leader” to arbitrate or mediate disputes, resolve family troubles, and correct behavior by allowing the criminal to perform community service may not work in such cases (Neilson, 1999, 108).  But, even the traditional criminal justice system does not serve its purpose in all cases.It is, therefore, best to consider a mix and match of heterogeneous crime deterrance techniques.  Unless a young offender is severely mentally ill, alternatives to the traditional criminal justice system, such as shaming, peacemaking strategies and restorative justice, may work best.Unless it is a rape, robbery or murder case, alternatives to the traditional system must also work best on adult offenders that have never received a legal notice in their lives.All that the victim desires is justice.  As Sherman & Strang (1997b) have maintained, if the perpetrator of a crime agrees not to repeat the offence, and manages to keep his or her word, it is absolutely correct to allow the individual to change his or her behavior by realizing h is or her folly.  This is the reason why social workers are firm believers in alternatives to the traditional criminal justice system (Wormer).The Contingency Theory should continue to play a central function in the justice system.  Every case brought in advance law enforcement personnel and courts of law is unique, and must be treated thus.  If everybody is treated as an equal, the criminal justice system would make a mockery of itself play the game of three blind mice †the ones given the delegate of meting out justice, the offenders, and the victims.Sane people do not want to be shamed or punished, and if they have erroneously offended others, are usually prepared to mend their ways especially when mediators are involved in the case.  Human beings have a natural semblance with each other.Almost everybody in the world shrieks in scourge at crimes perpetrated against humanity.  Therefore, it is most reasonable to consider the traditional criminal justice s ystem alongside the alternatives to the system.  more than correctly, it is necessary to put together the alternatives with the traditional criminal justice system and use the correct measures establish on the facts of each case.Just as everybody is not dishonest, all individuals cannot be expected to have the same level of intelligence or sense of responsibility toward society.ReferencesKemp, R. B. (2000, Mar). The U.S. penal System: Restorative and/or Retributive justice.Woodstock Report. Retrieved Nov 28, 2008, from http://woodstock.georgetown.edu/publications/ tale/r-fea61a.htm.Neilson, M. O. (1999). Navajo Nation Courts, Peacemaking, and Restorative Justice Issues.Journal of Legal Pluralism, Vol. 44. Retrieved Nov 28, 2008, fromhttp://www.jlp.bham.ac.uk/volumes/44/nielsen-art.pdf.Sherman, L. W., & Strang, H. (1997a, Apr). Restorative Justice and Deterring Crime.Australian Institute of Criminology. Retrieved Nov 28, 2008, fromhttp://www.aic.gov.au/rjustice/ sharpen/wor king/risepap4.html.———————————â€. (1997b, Apr). The right kind of shame for crime prevention.Australian Institute of Criminology. Retrieved Nov 28, 2008, from http://www.aic.gov.au/rjustice/rise/working/risepap1.html.Wormer, K. V. (2002, Jan 7). Restorative Justice and Social Work. Social Work Today, Vol. 2,No. 1. Retrieved Nov 28, 2008, fromhttp://www.restorativejustice.org/resources/docs/vanwormer/.\r\n'